The best leftover Christmas dessert ideas

How to use… leftover Christmas pudding

1. Christmas pudding cheesecake

Cheesecake topped with orange wheels and with a slice cut out

Combine two classic desserts to make a luxuriously creamy cheesecake. Blitz leftover pud with brandy to make a purée, then fold it into the cheesecake mixture. Spicy, creamy and sweet, the crunchy ginger biscuit base and caramelised clementine topping make this a dazzling dessert sure to convert the most ardent Christmas pudding haters.

2. Rye Christmas pudding cookies

Christmas cookies sandwiched with cream next to two flutes of alcohol

Christmas pudding is so versatile it can even be incorporated into cookie dough. Rye flour gives these soft and buttery biscuits a deep nutty flavour, which balances perfectly with the sweet, fruity pudding. Sandwich the cooled cookies with clotted cream or ice cream to make a decadent dessert.

3. Christmas pudding ice cream

Three scoops of Christmas pudding ice cream topped with toffee sauce

Christmas pudding freezes well and can be turned into an ice cream as easily as stirring some pieces into fresh custard (which can be homemade or shop-bought). This version has a hint of almondy amaretto and is best served with hot toffee sauce.

4. Ginger & Christmas pud cheesecake with ginger sauce

Ginger & Christmas pud cheesecake with ginger sauce on a white disposable plate

Not for the faint-hearted, this pudding combines leftover chunks of Christmas pudding with Jamaican ginger cake and stem ginger. Combine with a hot caramel sauce and you’ve got yourself one spicy pud to wake up the tastebuds.

More like this

5. Christmas pudding ice cream bombe

Christmas pudding ice cream bombe topped with drizzled chocolate and glaze cherries

Looking for something really special? Rework your leftover free-from Christmas pudding into a stunning ice cream bombe, drizzled in dark chocolate and topped with dried cranberries, glacé cherries and holly or bay leaves. This impressive dessert is gluten-free and can easily be made ahead and stored in the freezer. Perfect for a New Year’s Eve celebration.

6. Christmas pudding strudel

Christmas pudding strudel cut into slices, served on a white rectangular board

Throw a box of ready-made filo pastry into your Christmas shopping trolley, then use it to wrap up your pudding leftovers for a Boxing Day centrepiece. This log is best served warm from the oven with brandy butter, festive ice cream or hot custard.

7. Christmas pudding trifle

Christmas pudding trifle in a glass serving jar

Need a speedy post-Christmas dessert? Rustle up this sumptuous trifle in just 15 minutes, featuring a base layer of Christmas pudding topped with Grand Marnier-steeped oranges, custard and whipped cream.

For more ideas, watch our video on how to use up leftover Christmas pudding.

8. Vegan Christmas pudding brownies

Christmas pudding brownies on plates

Just about everyone can enjoy these chocolate brownies, which have been given a festive makeover with the addition of crumbled shop-bought free-from Christmas pudding and dairy-free chocolate chunks.

Leftover Christmas cake

9. Festive baked Alaska

Festive baked alaska with a large chunk taken out

Since it’s packed with lots of fruit, nuts and booze, Christmas cake can keep for months on end. However, if you don’t want yours lingering on until summer, use it up in this meringue dessert. The combination of hot topping and cold ice cream is a treat for the senses.

10. Christmas cake soufflés

Two Christmas cake souffles

Reinvent your leftover fruit cake or Christmas pudding in these light and fluffy soufflés. Pour a warm caramel sauce into each pot and watch as they magically melt in the centre.

Leftover mince pies

11. Mince pie brownies

Mince pie brownie squares

Bored of plain mince pies? This marvellous festive creation incorporates them into gooey chocolate brownies for an utterly moreish sweet treat. Once you’ve tried these squidgy squares, you won’t go back.

12. Mince pie cheesecake

Mince pie cheesecake topped with crumbled mince pie

Over-stocked on mince pies this year? Don’t let them go to waste! Why not give them a delicious second life by adding into the base of this cheesecake. A stroke of culinary genius, if we do say so ourselves, plus a brilliant way to beat Christmas food waste.

13. Frozen custard sundae

Frozen custard sundae served in 3 tall dessert glasses

This simple sundae uses up leftover mince pies and panettone by layering them with no-churn ice cream. We’ve used shop-bought salted caramel sauce, and you can swap mince pies for Christmas cake, pudding or crumbled yule log, if you like. Bashed biscuits, such as ginger nuts or shortbread, or chopped nuts and chocolate truffles, can also be used instead of toasted panettone. Top with chocolate sauce or raspberry coulis, if you like.

Leftover panettone

14. Panettone pudding

Bread and butter pudding made with panettone in an oval baking dish

Once this Italian fruit loaf is taken out of its decorative box, it goes stale quite quickly. Save it from the dustbin by soaking in a mix of eggs, cream and vanilla, then bake it. If that’s not decadent enough for you, serve with softly whipped cream.

Bake your own panettone for Christmas with our best panettone recipes.

15. Crunchy almond panettone French toast

Panettone French toast with sliced oranges on a plate, next to pot of cream

Transform leftover panettone into an indulgent brunch by coating it in a spiced clementine and almond egg mixture before frying to make French toast. Drizzle in maple syrup and scatter over pomegranate and clementine slices for a final festive flourish. It’s delicious served with yogurt or leftover brandy butter.

Leftover mincemeat

16. Mincemeat banana bread

Sliced mincemeat banana bread

Already the champion of leftovers, we’ve given banana bread a festive twist by flavouring it with mincemeat and mixed spice, then serving with a whipped cinnamon butter. Make it for a delicious breakfast or afternoon tea treat over the Christmas holidays.

17. Mincemeat cookies

Mincemeat cookies on a wire rack

Empty that half-used jar of mincemeat in the back of the cupboard by making these Christmas cookies. Simply beat a few tablespoons of mincemeat into the dough, scoop onto baking sheets and bake for 10-12 minutes. These crunchy cookies make a great last-minute addition to a Christmas dessert spread, or an edible gift for a loved one.

18. Christmas pavlova

One large Christmas pavlova

Transforming a jar of mincemeat into a pavlova might not be the first idea that springs to mind, but it’s a winner. Fold mincemeat into a rum-infused cream, then spoon this over meringue along with clementines, pistachios, mint and dark chocolate. This would also make a great centrepiece for New Year’s Eve.

Find creative recipes that make the most of the ends of a jar of mincemeat with our 10 new ways with mincemeat.

Leftover marzipan

19. Marzipan Eccles tarts

Marzipan Eccles tarts cut open on a white plate

Marzipan is a dry storecupboard ingredient that’ll last much longer than breads and cakes, but if you have a little left over and want to save the cupboard space, use it to enrich these Lancashire-inspired puff pastry bakes.

20. Marzipan & mincemeat apples

Four marzipan & mincemeat apples in an oven proof baking dish

For a lighter dessert option, serve baked apples with spoonfuls of mincemeat. Using only four ingredients, they’re so easy to make – and if you crave more indulgence, pour over lots of custard or fresh double cream.

Leftover stollen

21. Christmas stollen pudding

Christmas stollen pudding in an oven proof dish with serving spoon

Put this traditional Christmas bread to good use in a good, old-fashioned baked pudding. This recipe also uses up leftover amaretti biscuits for the topping, leaving regular bread & butter pudding with a serious image problem.

Leftover biscuits and sweets

22. Christmas rocky road

Rocky road on a board chopped into squares

The best part about this festive rocky road? You can adapt it by using whatever treats you have. Transform any leftover Christmas sweets and biscuits into this no-bake rocky road in just 25 minutes. This is a great recipe for getting the kids involved, too.

See more of our best rocky road recipes.

Discover more festive dessert recipes:

Christmas pudding recipes
Stollen recipes
Panettone recipes
Christmas cake recipes
Mince pie recipes
Marzipan recipes

Which desserts do you like to make with Christmas leftovers? Leave a comment below…

title_words_as_hashtags], 1700734845

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *